On the twenty third India-Russia summit-level talks right now (December 5) between Russian President Vladimir Putin and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, one of many matters which may have consumed extra time was the additional enlargement of nuclear cooperation between the 2 international locations.
In his much-talked-about interview with India Immediately on the eve of his journey to New Delhi, President Putin revealed that additional collaboration within the nuclear discipline might be one of many “most important” points he’ll talk about with Prime Minister Modi.
He had mentioned, “We’re producers of the world’s most superior and dependable tools for nuclear energy crops. The Russian firm Rosatom builds and operates extra nuclear reactors for nuclear energy crops overseas than some other firm on the planet – 22 nuclear items. The effectively‑identified facility and our joint undertaking, the Kudankulam plant ( India) , is among the leaders on this regard…..
“Russia might be the one nation on the planet right now able to constructing – and truly does construct – small nuclear energy crops. Such crops are already operational in Russia, and we will make them both floating or ground-based. It’s a superb possibility for particular areas the place huge energy stations should not wanted or the place connecting electrical energy grids between mills and end-users isn’t possible. These compact nuclear energy modules can thus be deployed in remoted and hard-to-access places.”
In truth, it was not a coincidence that yesterday (December 4), across the time Putin landed in Delhi, Rosatom introduced the supply of the primary batch of nuclear gasoline for the preliminary loading of the third reactor on the Kudankulam Nuclear Energy Plant (KNPP) in Tamil Nadu.
The crucial cargo was transported to the Kudankulam web site through a devoted cargo flight, touchdown on the day Putin arrived.
Reportedly, this cargo secures the lifetime gasoline provide for each the under-construction third and fourth VVER-1000 reactors at KNPP, beginning with the preliminary core loading for Unit 3.
It might be famous that the Kudankulam facility is the cornerstone of India’s civilian nuclear power program, designed to deal with six VVER-1000 reactors with a complete put in capability of 6,000 MW. The primary section of the plant, consisting of Items 1 and a couple of, was already related to the nationwide energy grid in 2013 and 2016, respectively.
Rosatom has famous that 4 different reactors, together with the not too long ago fueled Unit 3, are at numerous levels of development.
Be that as it could, the timing of Rosatom’s supply and Putin’s go to appears to have been well-planned from one other angle. Within the ongoing session of Parliament, Prime Minister Modi is reportedly within the means of amending India’s nuclear legal guidelines with the brand new Atomic Vitality Invoice, 2025.
These adjustments are a part of an effort to realize an bold goal of 100 GW of nuclear energy capability by 2047. The first aim of the proposed adjustments is to encourage non-public and international funding within the nuclear energy sector, which has traditionally been a state monopoly.
Additionally, India’s Civil Legal responsibility for Nuclear Harm Act (CLNDA), 2010, is deliberate to be amended to handle considerations from world suppliers relating to the “proper of recourse” provision, which permits the operator to hunt damages from the provider within the occasion of an accident attributable to defective tools. This provision has been a serious deterrent for international corporations.
India below Modi is actively enhancing its nuclear energy capability to fulfill rising power calls for and obtain environmental targets. The federal government has initiated steps to extend nuclear energy capability from the present 8,180 MW to 22,480 MW by 2031-32.
This enlargement plan consists of the development and commissioning of ten reactors, totalling 8,000 MW, throughout Gujarat, Rajasthan, Tamil Nadu, Haryana, Karnataka, and Madhya Pradesh. Moreover, pre-project actions for ten extra reactors have commenced, with plans for progressive completion by 2031-32.
In truth, a key spotlight of India’s Price range 2025-26 was the launch of a Nuclear Vitality Mission, specializing in analysis and growth (R&D) of Small Modular Reactors (SMRs). The federal government has allotted ₹20,000 crore ($2.5B) for this initiative, aiming to develop a minimum of 5 indigenously designed and operational SMRs by 2033.
And considerably, President Putin can be emphasising the opportunity of such SMRs in India by mentioning that such crops are already operational in Russia and that Russia may even float them on the ocean.
These may be appropriate for particular industrial and distant areas in India, too, he thinks, as this supplies Russia with a marketplace for its cutting-edge improvements.
One other factor that Putin may need taken under consideration is that regardless of the commerce hiccups between the US and India, the Modi authorities has accorded in-principle approval to arrange a 6 x 1208 MW nuclear energy plant in cooperation with the Washington at Kovvada in Srikakulam district within the state of Andhra Pradesh.
The purpose is that Russia is not going to like its first-mover benefit in India’s nuclear power market to be diluted by the entry of different international gamers, such because the U.S.
In truth, it’s ironic that although the landmark India-US civil nuclear settlement of 2005 lifted the worldwide isolation of India within the growth of peaceable nuclear power and lifted the worldwide sanctions on this discipline regardless that India isn’t a celebration to the NPT, a novel standing for India that was attainable due to the then U.S. President George Bush, it’s Russia, not America, that has reaped its actual dividends.
American corporations haven’t been in a position to enter India’s nuclear market due to CLANDA, which talks of compensation within the occasion of nuclear accidents in a plant.
CLNDA locations duty for any nuclear accident with the operator, as is customary internationally, and limits complete legal responsibility to round $450 million, or such increased quantity that the Central authorities could specify by notification.
Operator legal responsibility is capped at Rs 1,500 crore ($285 million) or such increased quantity that the Central authorities could notify, past which the Central authorities is liable, although the federal government legal responsibility quantity is restricted to the rupee equal of 300 million Particular Drawing Rights (SDRs).
Nonetheless, the bottleneck for the international corporations is that CLNDA, even after compensation has been paid by the operator (or its insurers), permits, via its clause 17(b), the operator to have authorized recourse to the provider for as much as 80 years after the plant begins up if within the opinion of an Indian court docket the “nuclear incident has resulted as a consequence of an act of provider or its worker, which incorporates provide of apparatus or materials with patent or latent defects or sub-standard providers.”
This clause giving the provider recourse for an operational plant is claimed to be opposite to worldwide conventions and to undermine the channeling precept basic to nuclear legal responsibility internationally. In addition to, no restrict has been set on suppliers’ legal responsibility. The provider group has interpreted this provision to be ambiguous and one which renders it weak to open-ended legal responsibility claims.
A second sticking level has been Part 46 of CLNDA, which states that the provisions of the Act ‘had been along with, and never in derogation of, some other legislation in the meanwhile in power’, resulting in considerations among the many suppliers that they could possibly be subjected to a number of and concurrent legal responsibility claims. The Act, in spite of everything, doesn’t forestall an individual from bringing proceedings towards the operator below any legislation apart from this Act. That would even permit legal legal responsibility to be pursued towards the operator and the provider, it’s feared.
Clearly, all potential nuclear suppliers, together with the U.S., to India have been sad. This, maybe, has led the Modi authorities to contemplate amending the Act in Parliament.
Nonetheless, not like the U.S., Russia has taken benefit of the Modi authorities’s present scheme for making a nuclear insurance coverage pool to fulfill any legal responsibility prices. Russia is the one nation that has expanded its nuclear cooperation in India by putting in extra reactors in Tamil Nadu (Kundakulam) after the enactment of CLNDA.
Every of Rosatom’s new items on the Kudankulam plant has been valued at $2.5 billion by India’s public sector Normal Insurance coverage Firm, with a 20-year insurance coverage premium charged to cowl Russia’s legal responsibility for an accident.
It’s towards this background that the joint assertion following right now’s summit offers with a separate heading on “Civil Nuclear Cooperation, Cooperation in House”. However essential to notice that of the 5 paragraphs or factors on this part, nuclear cooperation has been talked about in 4.
These are:
“The Sides confirmed their intention to broaden cooperation in nuclear power, together with gasoline cycle, life cycle assist for working Kudankulam Nuclear Energy Plant (KKNPP) and non-power functions, in addition to to elaborate a brand new agenda of interplay within the discipline of peaceable use of atomic power and associated excessive applied sciences. The Sides famous the significance of cooperation within the peaceable makes use of of nuclear power as a major factor of the strategic partnership, taking into consideration the plans of the Authorities of India to extend India’s nuclear power capability to 100 GW by 2047.
“The Sides welcomed the progress achieved within the implementation of KKNPP, together with the development of the remaining NPP ( Nuclear Energy Plant) items, and agreed on adhering to the timeline for provides of apparatus and gasoline.
“The Sides famous the significance of additional dialogue on the second web site in India for NPP; the Indian Facet will attempt to finalize formal allotment of the second web site in accordance with earlier signed agreements.
“The Sides agreed to speed up technical and industrial discussions on the VVER ( Water Strain Reactors) of the Russian design, analysis, and joint growth of NPPs, localization and joint manufacturing of nuclear tools and gasoline assemblies for Russian-designed giant capability NPPs topic to phrases and circumstances as mutually agreeable”.
It appears that evidently for Moscow, and this was fairly obvious in Putin’s aforesaid interview, India shouldn’t be seen solely as a profitable marketplace for Russia’s sources and know-how.
Nuclear cooperation is seen by it in strategic phrases. Strengthening ties with India supplies Russia a strategic counterbalance amid evolving world geopolitics. Russia is utilizing its place as one of many few international locations able to constructing a full spectrum of nuclear energy crops (together with giant items and small modular reactors) to keep up affect and technological management in a key space of world power transition.
- Writer and veteran journalist Prakash Nanda is Chairman of the Editorial Board of the EurAsian Instances and has been commenting on politics, international coverage, and strategic affairs for practically three many years. He’s a former Nationwide Fellow of the Indian Council for Historic Analysis and a recipient of the Seoul Peace Prize Scholarship.
- CONTACT: prakash.nanda (at) hotmail.com
Leave a Reply